Duel Academy Log in

Get your game on!


Share

pollWhat should be done with Day 1?

Prevent lynching on Day 1
4
25%
Shorten Day 1
8
50%
Both
4
25%
Keep it as it is
0
0%
Total Votes:
16

descriptionDA Mafia: Lynching on Day 1?

more_horiz
So last game, being able to lynch on Day 1 seemed to cause a lot of problems. Being honest, where I used to play, lynching on Day 1 wasnt even allowed in the first place. Do you think it should be allowed here? Do you think day 1 should be shorter? Do you think both? Or do you think none at all? Whichever choice gets the most votes by the time the hiatus is up will be implemented.


Achievments in spoiler.
Spoiler :
DA League S2, S9, and S11 winner
Chronos Survival Cup 3 Winner. TBUT2 and TBUT3 winner.
Won 29+ DA lives
DA Lives season 0, and season 1 winner.
Won more DA lives than anyone else. Alot more.
Supreme queen of May 2012, April-May 2013, and May 2014.
Three time Survival Master
My current DA record: Wins:451 Lost: 81 Draws: 6
Former Teacher and Assistant. Former Moderator.
First to ever reach the Abandoned Dark League
Moderator of the year 2013.
DA Regionals 2012 and 2013 top 4
Badass since 2011
First to ever pass the Slifer Exam, with a score of 34/35.
Much more.


descriptionRe: DA Mafia: Lynching on Day 1?

more_horiz
Lynching on day 1 is completely random imo so yeh i voted


-The scarlet comet-
SHADOW RIDERS

descriptionRe: DA Mafia: Lynching on Day 1?

more_horiz
I have voten both 3 day duration for Day 1 seems little bit too long in my opinion, and lynching feels random at Day 1. I have nothing against some general discussion at Day 1, but I hate when players random lynch. It leads us nowhere. 



"So we are staying in this mess, this beautiful mess tonight"
Why so serious? :3 

descriptionRe: DA Mafia: Lynching on Day 1?

more_horiz
I think that day one should be a short day that everyone can see who is playing and what roles are in the game. There shouldn't be any claiming roles or lynching.


If you kill me you take away this from the thread....

descriptionRe: DA Mafia: Lynching on Day 1?

more_horiz
I couldn't care less if there's lynching day one if there's a good reason for it.

And day one feels way too long




"Our largest regrets are not for things we did, but for things we did not do. Things we did not say; love that never could happen. We bury our regrets by promising to change our ways. But sometimes we don't get to change the past."

~Mr.Kandy

descriptionRe: DA Mafia: Lynching on Day 1?

more_horiz
This opinion's kinda weird but imo day1 lynches shouldn't happen but they should be allowed.
Day 1 conversations should be allowed and if a player's like waaaaay too scummy there shouldn't be a reason for them to not get lynched one;Also lynching is a great way to soft-claim and more importantly to bait people;If the evil roles know they can't get lynched they'll be way more laid-back and way less-stressed and can even turn the suspicious back on the person that's FoS-ing them back on themselves just cause they are playing agresive when they can't even lynch...


On another topic though as DMK said on another day(even though I guess deep down he just wanted the day to end so he could kill Crims) : Day 1 should be a rather short day,the day sometimes ends up being way too boring for the lack of information/plans(for mafia) and the vote just being a random one since it kinda feels bad to achieve "nothing" after a long day so it honestly feels better to go for an RNG vote instead of voting no one(though it's never truly "nothing" gained from a post in mafia...even an empty one)


So voting shorter day 1 but keep the vote.


jjh927:sacker -_-

Amy Kool :
[05:06:21] @ Amy Kool : kaiba talks about screwing the rules but yugi actually does the shit

Achivements :
Survival Tourney second place-12/1/2013
Deck Master Lord tourney second place
DA's underdog of the year-2013
DA world cup 2nd place 8/25/2014

descriptionRe: DA Mafia: Lynching on Day 1?

more_horiz
Shorter day 1, keep the RNG lynch. The way it was it was boring as heck.


My biggest accomplishment so far here on DA
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
[10:49:39] N : I'm proud of you
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
pig 

descriptionRe: DA Mafia: Lynching on Day 1?

more_horiz
I'd explain my choice, but it's literally impossible to reason with you guys so I'm just going to vote.



Yes, I am a dickhead.

descriptionRe: DA Mafia: Lynching on Day 1?

more_horiz
I'd like to hear the explanation. .-. No need to try to reason or fight, lol. Just say what you mean then leave.


My biggest accomplishment so far here on DA
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
[10:49:39] N : I'm proud of you
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
Spoiler :
pig 

descriptionRe: DA Mafia: Lynching on Day 1?

more_horiz
@hazmah wrote:
I'd explain my choice, but it's literally impossible to reason with you guys so I'm just going to vote.


Why are you then posting this? You could just vote and leave  



"So we are staying in this mess, this beautiful mess tonight"
Why so serious? :3 

descriptionRe: DA Mafia: Lynching on Day 1?

more_horiz
I agree with everyone.


janine bunag Smile Smile Smile Smile

descriptionRe: DA Mafia: Lynching on Day 1?

more_horiz
@Lux wrote:
@hazmah wrote:
I'd explain my choice, but it's literally impossible to reason with you guys so I'm just going to vote.


Why are you then posting this? You could just vote and leave  

OOOOOOOO

MA BOI LUX GETTING FEISTY!

And don't bs me by saying you aren't, you clearly have a hint of animosity by saying that.

Anyway, it's to try to make a point. You never done that before???



Yes, I am a dickhead.

descriptionRe: DA Mafia: Lynching on Day 1?

more_horiz
Just gonna tell everyone to chill their tits before this becomes a thing.


Achievments in spoiler.
Spoiler :
DA League S2, S9, and S11 winner
Chronos Survival Cup 3 Winner. TBUT2 and TBUT3 winner.
Won 29+ DA lives
DA Lives season 0, and season 1 winner.
Won more DA lives than anyone else. Alot more.
Supreme queen of May 2012, April-May 2013, and May 2014.
Three time Survival Master
My current DA record: Wins:451 Lost: 81 Draws: 6
Former Teacher and Assistant. Former Moderator.
First to ever reach the Abandoned Dark League
Moderator of the year 2013.
DA Regionals 2012 and 2013 top 4
Badass since 2011
First to ever pass the Slifer Exam, with a score of 34/35.
Much more.


descriptionRe: DA Mafia: Lynching on Day 1?

more_horiz
Hi.

Anyway lynching day 1 is great and healthy since your lynches are going to be very important to kill anti-town, especially to read through the players who went ON a lynch, and why to analyze wagons to help advance the game and figure out who scum is.

To address the "Day 1 lynch being random"...I don't understand that.

There's a difference between a reason for a lynch being random than for reasons such as scummy behavior and how to identify it.

Now good old Jolly in the last game wanted to vote Crim for the "lols and a good Crim lynch would be amazing!" That in itself and the whole "lols" mentality shouldn't be in the game to begin with and be scrutinized with policy for not taking the game seriously. It's a fun game that you should not fool around with that late into a day phase. Joking is all fine near the beginning but you need to focus in on your team wincon eventually.

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?p=4025162

This is what I've wanted to link for a while.

On the subject of shortening day 1, I voted for that initially, but I suppose I should have put nothing since you didn't rlly specify how long you'd shorten it. I should have known better since Day 1 is the most important day to kick the game off. I've been used to 24 hr day and night phases, so the longer phases took me by surprise.

descriptionRe: DA Mafia: Lynching on Day 1?

more_horiz
The actual length of the day will depend on how many players are in.


Achievments in spoiler.
Spoiler :
DA League S2, S9, and S11 winner
Chronos Survival Cup 3 Winner. TBUT2 and TBUT3 winner.
Won 29+ DA lives
DA Lives season 0, and season 1 winner.
Won more DA lives than anyone else. Alot more.
Supreme queen of May 2012, April-May 2013, and May 2014.
Three time Survival Master
My current DA record: Wins:451 Lost: 81 Draws: 6
Former Teacher and Assistant. Former Moderator.
First to ever reach the Abandoned Dark League
Moderator of the year 2013.
DA Regionals 2012 and 2013 top 4
Badass since 2011
First to ever pass the Slifer Exam, with a score of 34/35.
Much more.


descriptionRe: DA Mafia: Lynching on Day 1?

more_horiz
@Linda-Senpai wrote:
The actual length of the day will depend on how many players are in.

How does amount of players correlate to length of day? I mean, I can understand if it's like 12 compared to 25, but I'm (no offense) sure the maximum you can get is 15. That's not going to vary the game too much.



Yes, I am a dickhead.

descriptionRe: DA Mafia: Lynching on Day 1?

more_horiz
@hazmah wrote:
@Linda-Senpai wrote:
The actual length of the day will depend on how many players are in.

How does amount of players correlate to length of day? I mean, I can understand if it's like 12 compared to 25, but I'm (no offense) sure the maximum you can get is 15. That's not going to vary the game too much.

Because I want everyone to actually get a chance to post.

The hiatus is up, so I'll be locking this. Shorten Day 1 wins the poll.


Achievments in spoiler.
Spoiler :
DA League S2, S9, and S11 winner
Chronos Survival Cup 3 Winner. TBUT2 and TBUT3 winner.
Won 29+ DA lives
DA Lives season 0, and season 1 winner.
Won more DA lives than anyone else. Alot more.
Supreme queen of May 2012, April-May 2013, and May 2014.
Three time Survival Master
My current DA record: Wins:451 Lost: 81 Draws: 6
Former Teacher and Assistant. Former Moderator.
First to ever reach the Abandoned Dark League
Moderator of the year 2013.
DA Regionals 2012 and 2013 top 4
Badass since 2011
First to ever pass the Slifer Exam, with a score of 34/35.
Much more.


descriptionRe: DA Mafia: Lynching on Day 1?

more_horiz
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum